A closer look at… Still Alice

Note: Guides from our archive are in a slightly different format and have been edited here to make them more user-friendly.

still-alice-movie-poster

At the age of fifty, Alice Howland (Julianne Moore) has everything she wants: a prestigious job as a linguistics professor, a loving husband (Alec Baldwin), and three grown-up children. Life doesn’t seem about to slow down any time soon. But then Alice begins experiencing some unnerving memory lapses, and after a series of tests, she receives the devastating news that she has early-onset Alzheimer’s.

The disease, which she may have passed on to her children, will gradually take away her memories until she no longer knows who she is. For this sharp, competent, independent woman, it’s a crushing blow, and only her youngest daughter Lydia (Kristen Stewart) seems to really understand. As Alice goes into decline, she and those who love her must come to terms with everything they’re going to lose.

Dig Deeper

  • What was your first reaction to the film, and why? How much did you know about it before going in, and was it what you expected?
  • How do the filmmakers communicate Alice’s experience through the shooting style of the film? What techniques do they use, and how successful are these in evoking the first-hand experience of Alzheimer’s?
  • What did you think of Julianne Moore’s central performance? What qualities does she bring to the role of Alice, and how does she portray each stage of the character’s decline? Do you think she was deserving of the Best Actress Oscar?
  • The directors aimed to give the film a ‘crisp and direct tone’. Do you think that they achieved this, and what might make it an appropriate way of approaching the story? Can you think of any films with tragic subject matter which are the opposite of ‘crisp and direct’? What might be the pitfalls and advantages of each approach?

Julianne Moore as Alice in the movie STILL ALICE, directed by Richard Glatzer. Photo Credit: Denis Lenoir

  • How does the film portray Alice’s relationships with her family members? Why do you think that she and Lydia grow closer after her diagnosis?
  • Which scenes in Still Alice did you find the most powerful and moving, and why? How did you feel when you left the cinema, and what lasting impact might the film have on you?

‘I wish I had cancer. I wouldn’t feel so ashamed.’ – Alice

Why might there by more ‘shame’ associated with neurological or mental illnesses than with physical ones? How does our culture perceive people with Alzheimer’s, and does the film do anything to overturn these perceptions?

‘I feel like I can’t find myself. I’ve always been so defined by my intellect.’ – Alice

  • How is Alice ‘defined by her intellect’, and what challenges does this raise for her as her mental function becomes impaired? To what extent does our culture define people by their intellect, or by their other competencies? What implications might this have when these competencies are lost, whether because of illness, age, or something else?

alice1

‘You’re a better man than I am.’ – John, to Lydia

  • What did you make of John, Alice’s husband? How does he view Alice’s decline, and in your view, is he right not to take a break from his own career? Is he right to consider Lydia’s reaction ‘better’ than his own, and is there any ‘right’ response to the kind of situation which Alice’s family are in?
  • Some critics questioned Still Alice‘s decision to foreground a younger, more ‘photogenic’ Alzheimer’s sufferer, given that the condition is far more prevalent in older people.In your view, does the film imply that Alice’s situation is particularly tragic because she is young, and would it be wrong to do so? To what extent might Alice’s privileged life circumstances (wealth, education, a supportive family) lead to a skewed view on what it’s like to live with Alzheimer’s?
  • Does the film draw any conclusions about the topic of euthanasia? How does it present Alice’s attempt to set up her future suicide, and the eventual outcome of this plan? Does Still Alice have anything to say about what ultimately makes life worth living, or what makes human beings intrinsically valuable?

alice

‘How can others take us seriously? But this is not who we are.’ – Alice

  • Does the film draw any conclusions about whether Alice is really ‘still Alice’ by the end of the story? In your view, is there any such thing as an intrinsic personal identity which can’t be destroyed, even if our memories are? If so, what constitutes this identity – and if not, what deeper problems might this raise for what it means to be human?

‘Nothing’s lost forever. In this world, there’s a kind of painful progress. Longing for what we’ve left behind, and dreaming ahead.’ – Tony Kushner, Angels in America

  • Lydia reads this speech from the play Angels in America in the film’s final scene. How does it resonate with Alice’s situation, and what final message does it leave the audience with? How do you interpret the idea that ‘nothing’s lost forever’, and in what sense – if any – might this be true?

187 thoughts on “A closer look at… Still Alice”

  1. Pingback: click to go
  2. Pingback: see more
  3. Pingback: more on the page
  4. Pingback: link to the page
  5. Pingback: read article
  6. Pingback: read article
  7. Pingback: read article
  8. Pingback: taken from here
  9. Pingback: notehub.org
  10. Pingback: taken from here
  11. Pingback: notehub.org
  12. Pingback: continue reading
  13. Pingback: visit web page
  14. Pingback: visit the page
  15. Pingback: notehub.org
  16. Pingback: here
  17. Pingback: notehub.org
  18. Pingback: notehub.org
  19. Pingback: click to continue
  20. Pingback: notehub.org go
  21. Pingback: notehub.org
  22. Pingback: notehub.org
  23. Pingback: Autoapprove List
  24. Pingback: comment640
  25. Pingback: comment261
  26. Pingback: comment940
  27. Pingback: comment558
  28. Pingback: comment789
  29. Pingback: comment302
  30. Pingback: comment279
  31. Pingback: comment727
  32. Pingback: comment788
  33. Pingback: comment997
  34. Pingback: comment566
  35. Pingback: comment404
  36. Pingback: comment973
  37. Pingback: comment332
  38. Pingback: comment815
  39. Pingback: comment680
  40. Pingback: comment897
  41. Pingback: comment697
  42. Pingback: comment71
  43. Pingback: comment908
  44. Pingback: comment234
  45. Pingback: comment474
  46. Pingback: comment698
  47. Pingback: comment377
  48. Pingback: comment669
  49. Pingback: comment92
  50. Pingback: comment70
  51. Pingback: comment8
  52. Pingback: comment650
  53. Pingback: comment113
  54. Pingback: comment627
  55. Pingback: comment419
  56. Pingback: comment777
  57. Pingback: comment545
  58. Pingback: comment85
  59. Pingback: comment473
  60. Pingback: comment681
  61. Pingback: comment381
  62. Pingback: comment805
  63. Pingback: comment189
  64. Pingback: comment495
  65. Pingback: comment955
  66. Pingback: comment809
  67. Pingback: comment56
  68. Pingback: comment901
  69. Pingback: more on the page
  70. Pingback: 554cU5uZUOP
  71. Pingback: hdmobilesex.me
  72. Pingback: pronvipse.mobi
  73. Pingback: pronbestrank.mobi
  74. Pingback: visit web page
  75. Pingback: xxxvipsearch.mobi
  76. Pingback: click to go
  77. Pingback: topsexportal.mobi
  78. Pingback: more on the page
  79. Pingback: go to the page
  80. Pingback: address
  81. Pingback: 2019

Comments are closed.